Build Your Winning Roster:
Hiring CSRs, Leaders, and Sales Reps for the Year Ahead
Kick Off the Year with a Strong Call Center Staffing Game Plan
September may be the kickoff to Football season, but January is the kickoff for call centers. It’s when leaders either set the tone for a strong season or start behind on the scoreboard. The companies that draft the right players early are the ones winning customer loyalty, while everyone else scrambles with overtime, burnout, and long hold queues.
According to SHRM, the average time to fill a role in the U.S. stretches well past a month. That means call centers that wait until November are already behind. Experienced leaders plan staffing needs early, forecasting seat demand based on last year’s call volumes, turnover patterns, and seasonal growth targets.
Based on Hiregy’s 20+ years of experience, we’ve seen that leaders who act now avoid last-minute scrambles and protect both revenue and customer satisfaction when it matters most.
This isn’t about playing it safe. It’s about being strategic. Let’s look at the three roles that matter most going into peak season: CSRs, Call Center Leaders, and Sales Reps.
CSRs: The Offensive Line Protecting Your Customer Experience
When call volumes spike, CSRs are your offensive line. They take the hits, protect the play, and give your team a chance to score. A strong rep keeps the customer experience moving forward. A weak one leaves you vulnerable to turnovers, customers walking away for good.
The truth is, CSRs don’t have to be perfect at every technical skill on day one. Tools and systems can be taught. What’s harder to teach is empathy and active listening. In fact, customer experience experts say active listening is one of the top traits that separates a rep who survives peak season from one who thrives.
Why Empathy Is the Play That Wins Customers
Think of empathy as the rep’s “superpower.” It’s what helps them turn an angry caller into a loyal advocate. In interviews, push candidates to describe a time when they turned a negative customer experience around. Strong candidates will be able to recall details, the situation, their actions, and the outcome. Weak ones will stay vague.
Here’s the catch: you can’t wait until November to build that team.
New year hiring should start eight to ten weeks before the rush. By then, you’re not only competing for candidates, you’re fighting against training bottlenecks and scheduling headaches. Start earlier, and you can onboard CSRs in waves so they’re ready before hold times double.
Call Center Leaders:
Quarterbacks Who Drive Team Performance
If CSRs are the offensive line, leaders are the quarterbacks. They don’t just manage the play clock, they read the defense, call audibles, and keep everyone aligned. A strong leader elevates the entire team, while a weak one stalls the drive.
Our Hiregy call center staffing experts remind us that September is one of the busiest hiring seasons of the year. That means if you need a new team leader or supervisor for Q1, you can’t afford to drag your feet. Leadership roles have longer notice periods, and the last thing you want is a team walking into the new year with a vacant captain’s chair.
And the cost of waiting isn’t just abstract. In our own breakdown of the hidden costs of internal hiring, we showed how factors like lost manager time, job board fees, and turnover risk quickly add up. Even if you already have recruiters on payroll, every hour they spend sourcing and screening takes them away from higher-value work. And if a hire doesn’t stick, you’re back at square one with an even bigger bill.
The best interview question here? “Tell me about a time you improved retention or shortened ramp time. What exactly did you do?” Leaders who can’t answer with specifics aren’t leaders who can carry you through peak season.
See the RealNumbers for Yourself
It’s one thing to talk about the hidden costs of unfilled roles. It’s another to actually see how much money your call center is losing every week. That’s where our Cost of an Empty Seat Worksheet comes in.
With just a few simple inputs — like call volume, conversion rate, and revenue per interaction — you’ll get a clear, dollar-based estimate of the Contribution Value of each role on your team.
Leaders nationwide have used this tool to:
-
Make the business case for faster hiring
-
Show executives the real impact of open seats
-
Plan smarter staffing strategies backed by data
Don’t guess what vacancies are costing you. Calculate it. Then use those numbers to protect your revenue and your team.
Sales Reps: Playmakers Who Put Points on the Board
Sales reps are your wide receivers and running backs, the ones who move the chains and put points on the board. Interviewing them is tricky, because plenty can run routes in practice, but far fewer deliver when the stadium lights are on. That’s why structured interviews are critical.
Research from HubSpot, points to the same truth: strong sales reps can talk about their numbers. Ask about pipeline math, win rates, or prospecting routines. Great candidates will have the details ready. Poor ones will dodge specifics.
Role plays are golden here. Give them two minutes to open a conversation with a skeptical buyer. Throw an objection at them and see how they react. According to Zendesk, role-plays reveal whether someone can think on their feet. Mailshake adds that probing questions about losses (like “Tell me about a deal you lost and what you changed”) separate coachable reps from finger-pointers.
The stakes here are high. A bad sales hire doesn’t just waste a seat. It drags down revenue, demotivates the team, and leaves your pipeline weaker than before. You need people who stay steady when the lights are brightest and gonna be golden.
And remember: every empty sales seat isn’t just a gap in the org chart, it’s a measurable revenue leak. That’s why we built our Cost of an Empty Seat Worksheet. With just a few quick inputs, you can calculate the weekly dollar value each rep delivers, and exactly how much is being left on the table when a role goes unfilled.
Proof in Action: A Case Study
Recently, a healthcare call center came to Hiregy facing a seasonal surge they couldn’t manage alone. Their internal team was maxed out, overtime was climbing, and service levels were slipping. We stepped in, cut their time-to-hire by 40%, saved over $130,000 in recruiting and onboarding costs, and helped them retain 70% of their workforce well past the surge.
That’s the difference between barely finishing the season and making a playoff run.
Draft Your Winning Team for the Year Ahead
Hiring CSRs and leaders is challenging. Hiring sales reps can feel impossible. Even experienced managers struggle to separate the smooth talkers from the closers.
You don’t have to do this alone. The start of the year is the moment to act, and we’re ready to help you hire smarter, faster, and with less stress.. Book a call now, and let’s make this your strongest year yet.
More Insights from the Call Center Staffing Experts
From hiring tips to leadership strategies, our blog is your go-to resource for call center success. Dive into more articles from the staffing experts at Hiregy
Attracting and Retaining Employees
Given today’s competitive job market, your organization needs to be on top of its game to attract and retain the brightest minds. And as employee expectations evolve, it’s also important to reevaluate your hiring and retentions strategies continually to stay ahead.
How to find accounting jobs in Jacksonville Florida
Finance professionals will discover plenty of openings for rewarding accounting jobs in Jacksonville, Fl. What possibilities exist in the job market? This article explores the types of available roles, key qualifications, valued skills, job search strategies, career growth potential, and more.
The Secret to Getting Great Information from Candidate Interviews
Interviewing candidates is a critical step in the hiring process. But how do you structure interviews to extract truly valuable insights? What techniques elicit detailed responses? How can you encourage authenticity and assess both hard and soft skills?